WH-questions without WH-words
نویسنده
چکیده
Such WH-less WH-Questions (let us call them WLWQs) are very often used as questions in written tests or uttered by quizmasters in quizzes, though not often in daily conversations. 2 I assume that, despite their restriction in the range of registers, WLWQs are also constrained by the knowledge of human language. To my knowledge, there has been no previous research on WLWQs in the field. This paper discusses some syntactic issues as to WLWQs. In the course of discussions, I try to argue among others: (i) WLWQs differ in several syntactic aspects from other reduced expressions like VP ellipsis, gapping, pseudogapping, and other shortened wh-questions (section 2); (ii) they also differ from the cleft construction despite apparent similarities in interpreation (section 3); the overtly realized parts in WLWQs are topics (section 4); they read as subjects but not as other grammatical functions like objects or adjuncts due to the principle of deletion up to recoverability, which applies to elliptical structures in general (section 5); they do not have a non-interrogative reading due to a general principle constraining information structures (section 6); and nominative (as opposed to topic) WLWQs do not exist because of the restriction on phases (Chomsky 1998) (section 6). In the appendix, I discuss a potential conceptual problem that WLWQs face with respect to the feature copying mechanism and suggest possible solutions.
منابع مشابه
Wh-Questions\' Expression in Persian-speaking Children: A Comparison Between Spontaneous and Elicited Probes
Objectives: Studies have shown that most children before the age of 5 are capable to comprehend and express wh-questions in daily conversations. This study aimed at comparing the ability of wh-questions’ production in 4- to 6-year-old children in spontaneous and elicited conditions. Methods: In this descriptive-analytic study, 4- to 6-year-old Persian-speaking children (N = 72) were selected r...
متن کاملComplementiser Phrase: The Case of English Wh-Embedded Clauses
English main-clause wh-questions form complementiser phrases with wh-words preposed to spec-C position. This is because English wh-words, as verb-complements originally, are strong enough to trigger wh-movement and auxiliary inversion. Persian EFL learners encounter an over-differentiation problem regarding the acquisition of auxiliary inversion rule in English standard questions. Once they hav...
متن کاملThe Acquisition of WH questions by Persian and English speaking children
This research is case study which was designed to investigate the acquisition of WH-question byPersian and English speaking children between 2 to 4 years old. Four girls and their input wereprecisely analyzed in order to figure how WH-questions are effective in their speaking in theirdaily lives. In the current study the subjects were randomly selected and the matter of gender wasnot considered...
متن کاملNominalization and WH-movement in Seediq and Tagalog
This paper proposes a structural analysis of two types of wh-question formation in the Austronesian languages Seediq and Tagalog. Wh-questions formed on arguments are pseudo-cleft constructions; the wh-word functions as a predicate taking the rest of the clause, in the form of a headless relative, as its subject. The restriction that argument wh-questions can only be formed on absolutives is ac...
متن کاملReverse Long-distance Dependency and Functional Uncertainty - The Interpretation of Mandarin Questions
Mandarin Chinese WH-questions exhibit two syntactically interesting characteristics. First, WH-words that bear interrogative information always occur in situ. Second, in spite the above fact, I find that Mandarin WH-questions, with bounded WH-words, share the grammatical behaviors common to questions with unbounded and dislocated WH-words in other languages. Hence, intuitively, an account of Ma...
متن کاملReverse Long-distance Dependency and Functional
Mandarin Chinese WH-questions exhibit two syntactically interesting characteristics. First, WH-words that bear interrogative information always occur in situ.Second, in spite the above fact, I find that Mandarin WH-questions, with bounded WH-words, share the grammatical behaviors common to questions with unbounded and dislocated WH-words in other languages.Hence,intuitively,an account of Mandar...
متن کامل